Saturday, November 10, 2012

#Libya , U.S. faces tough choice: work with weak govt or with the militias:


After committing $ 8m to Counterterrorism in Libya , U.S. faces tough choice: work with weak govt or with the militias: 


U.S.-backed force in Libya faces challenges

ABDULLAH DOMA/AFP/GETTY IMAGES - Libyans stand at the site of a car bomb explosion as shattered glass lies on the ground, outside a police station, in Libya's second city of Benghazi on early Nov. 4, 2012. The attack comes as the country's new authorities try to empower the national army and police but struggle to rein in armed militias.
TRIPOLI — After committing $8 million to help build a counterterrorism force in Libya, the United States faces a difficult choice: work through a weak government that has so far proved unable to build a national army and police force from the thousands of former rebels who have operated as militias since Moammar Gaddafi’s downfall — or work with the militias themselves.
The deadly Sept. 11 attack on the U.S. mission in Benghazi underscored what many here say is a growing extremist problem amid Libya’s lawlessness. Most Libyan lawmakers are welcoming an Obama administration decision — made shortly before the Benghazi attack — to help Libya establish a special counterterrorism force.
Gallery

Petraeus resignation: Who is Paula Broadwell?

Petraeus resignation: Who is Paula Broadwell?
Petraeus' s reported love interest was a high achiever who saw him as a mentor.

Why David Petraeus’s Gmail account is a national security issue

Why David Petraeus’s Gmail account is a national security issue
If the CIA director let Paula Broadwell compromise his e-mail security, the implications are enormous.

Why Obamas trip to Burma is such a big deal

Why Obamas trip to Burma is such a big deal
The astonishingly rapid detente could send a message beyond just Asia.

Did Petraeus have to resign?

Theories abound as to how an affair can become a security risk.
But unlike Pakistan and Yemen, where U.S. Special Forces have helped train elite counterterrorism units, Libya presents no obvious security partner.
The Libyan government remains largely ineffective, with its military and police force still in the embryonic stage. Many militia members are armed, disciplined and ready to work. But Libyan officials and analysts say their participation in such a force could undermine the very goal of establishing a strong and unified post-war Libya.
Last week, a U.S. Embassy delegation, led by CIA operatives, traveled to Benghazi to meet and recruit fighters directly from the Libyan Shield, a powerful umbrella organization of militias, according to Fathi al-Obeidi, a commander of the group.
The Libyan Shield provided the rescue force that assisted the U.S. mission in Benghazion the night of the attack, and Obeidi said his fighters represent the most viable local option for a special unit.
The U.S. Embassy in Tripoli could not be reached for comment, and Lt. Col. James Gregory, a Pentagon spokesman, said that U.S. officials were still in the preliminary stages of the program and had not yet determined the size or composition of the force.
It was also unclear whether the visit described by Obeidi was part of the $8 million Defense Department initiative or a separate project.
But interviews with Obeidi and other militia commanders, as well as elected officials and the commander of Libya’s armed forces — each of whom offered a different interpretation of where power lies in the country — underscored the complex reality that U.S. officials will have to navigate if the program moves forward.
Analysts said the task of choosing a viable security partner from among disparate and competing factions in Libya’s security vacuum is loaded with potential pitfalls.
“There are enormous risks,” said Geoff Porter, a risk and security analyst who specializes in North Africa