#News


 Weather Maps

Monday, March 19, 2012

What Archaeologists Really Think About Ancient Aliens, Lost Colonies, And Fingerprints Of The Gods

What Archaeologists Really Think About Ancient Aliens, Lost Colonies, And Fingerprints Of The Gods

Kristina Killgrove
Kristina KillgroveSenior Contributor
ScienceArchaeologist, Writer, Scientist

(Photo by Patrick Aventurier/Getty Images)
It's no secret that far more people watch TV shows like the History Channel's 'Ancient Aliens' than attend lectures by professional archaeologists and historians.  Millions of people tune in to watch TV series and docu-dramas with a questionable grip on facts about the past.  The stories spun by producers and writers may have some basis in truth, but they're largely stories -- they're compelling stories, though, and they're aimed at a general audience the way that most academic output isn't.
People are also reading books about ancient aliens and other forms of pseudoarchaeology, according to archaeologist Donald Holly. He starts a recent open-access book review section in the journal American Antiquity by asking archaeologists to entertain the idea of pseudoarchaeology -- just for a little bit -- so that we can create better teachable moments, whether we're talking to students or to anyone interested in our jobs.  People who read these books are not ignorant or obstinate, he points out, but rather undecided about alternative archaeological explanations and clearly interested in understanding the past.  "It's time we talk to the guy sitting next to us on the airplane," Holly asserts.  In collecting nine reviews of popular-on-Amazon pseudo-archaeology books by professional archaeologists, Holly hopes that this will both "offer the silent and curious majority that is interested in these works a professional perspective on them" and give archaeologists unfamiliar with the books a pseudoarchaeology primer.
The article starts out with two reviews of books whose main premise is that we need advanced humans -- or nonhumans -- to make sense of past developments. First up, Graham Hancock's Fingerprints of the Gods: The Evidence of Earth's Lost Civilization, reviewed by Ken Feder, an archaeologist famous for his anti-pseudoarchaeology book Frauds, Myths, and Mysteries: Science and Pseudoscience in Archaeology. The gist of Fingerprints is that an extraordinarily advanced civilization roamed the seas thousands of years ago, giving advice to the people they found in places like Egypt and Peru and helping them establish their own civilizations. In return, these advanced peoples were treated as gods, particularly after some cataclysmic event wiped them out. Feder's main problems with Hancock's book include the fact that he cherry-picked his data, not bothering to address all the evidence; that he relies on very old and discredited fringe thinkers; and that he can't conceive of cultural evolution.

Read More: Archaeologists to Ben Carson: Ancient Egyptians Wrote Down Why The Pyramids Were Built
In the second review, The Ancient Alien Question, archaeologist Jeb Card points out, as does Feder, that the origins of this idea lay in Victorian mysticism and Theosophy, a movement that "blended hermetic magic, spiritualism, Western curiosity abut Eastern religion, colonial racism, and misconceptions of evolution into a worldview of root races, lost continents, and ascended masters who originated on Venus or other worlds." The author of The Ancient Alien Question, Philip Coppens, was a regular on the Ancient Aliens TV series and presents academic research as if science itself is mysterious. Most problematic, Card finds, is Coppens' invokation of "the destruction of the Library of Alexandria and other book burnings as suppression of ancient truth without recognizing his own call for the destruction of the scientific order, replacing scientific investigation with a new history of mysticism and myth."
Posted by Robby Ball at 5:09 PM
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Newer Post Older Post Home

MELANIA TRUMP - Media Has A Blackout On Reporting Anything Positive About Our Beautiful First Lady @FLOTUS https://t.co/a6bSDew8Rn

— Robby Ball (@perfectsliders) January 1, 2019

What was your reason for joining Twitter?

— Robby Ball (@perfectsliders) January 2, 2019
��RETWEET��Do u still STAND w Pres Donald Trump who is constantly attacked Need 2 let him know #Maga #satchat #Comey #KAG

— Robby Ball (@perfectsliders) June 10, 2017

��RETWEET��Do u still STAND w Pres Donald Trump who is constantly attacked Need 2 let him know

— Robby Ball (@perfectsliders) June 23, 2018

Search

Last year

  • Video #Ancient Knowledge, Pyramids, Monuments & Megaliths, Ley Lines
  • Atlantis Found
  • (no title)
  • Aisha pic Daughter Gaddafi
  • Another great day on the links! Thank you to POTUS for having me and to EVERYONE at Trump International for being so wonderful. What a great man, so down to earth and so fun to be with!! KEEP AMERICA GREAT!! -Kid Rock
  • #Mayan #Sumerians (5000 years ago -the same time that the #Maya Calendar began with the Fifth Great Cycle in 3114 BC
  • Videos - Summary last 24 hrs, maps Zliten and Al-Khums, reports FF holding ground
  • Protesters in Libya said they have claimed control over Wazen border crossing with Tunisia and about 100 of pro-Gaddafi forces fled across the terminal into Tunisia, al-Jazeera news channel reported on Thursday.
  • Herodotus describes thepeoples and geography of North Africa west of Egypt - much further west than the current boundaries of modern Libya
  • Video #Syria Assad's massacre in Souk Wadi Barada village conducted with a car bombing

Last 30 days

  • Video #Ancient Knowledge, Pyramids, Monuments & Megaliths, Ley Lines
  • Atlantis Found
  • "Forces loyal to President Bashar al-Assad have stormed a small farming village in central Syria
  • Aisha pic Daughter Gaddafi
  • #Egypt’s state-run news agency says 10 ministers have been replaced in the new cabinet reshuffle
  • #Syria l Assad Drops Food to Doomed Division 17 Soldiers as Rebels Surround Base #Raqqa
  • #DNA #Atlantis DNA analysis on Native Americans found DNA from Spain, Bulgaria, Finland, Italy, and Israel
  • Three #Packers wide receivers missed practice on Wednesday
  • 3000 BC The Libyan, or 3rd race of Africa, refers to Caucasian North Africans, Ethiopian is the classical term for black Africans, custom is for each man to have many wives
  • Another great day on the links! Thank you to POTUS for having me and to EVERYONE at Trump International for being so wonderful. What a great man, so down to earth and so fun to be with!! KEEP AMERICA GREAT!! -Kid Rock

How Many

Search This Blog

Last 7 days

  • Video #Ancient Knowledge, Pyramids, Monuments & Megaliths, Ley Lines
  • Atlantis Found
  • "Forces loyal to President Bashar al-Assad have stormed a small farming village in central Syria
  • Aisha pic Daughter Gaddafi
  • #Egypt’s state-run news agency says 10 ministers have been replaced in the new cabinet reshuffle
  • #Syria l Assad Drops Food to Doomed Division 17 Soldiers as Rebels Surround Base #Raqqa
  • #DNA #Atlantis DNA analysis on Native Americans found DNA from Spain, Bulgaria, Finland, Italy, and Israel
  • Three #Packers wide receivers missed practice on Wednesday
  • 3000 BC The Libyan, or 3rd race of Africa, refers to Caucasian North Africans, Ethiopian is the classical term for black Africans, custom is for each man to have many wives
  • Another great day on the links! Thank you to POTUS for having me and to EVERYONE at Trump International for being so wonderful. What a great man, so down to earth and so fun to be with!! KEEP AMERICA GREAT!! -Kid Rock

Search Date

Best of all Time

  • HOW HAS TRUMP DONE? Our favorite CNN says 40% give him an "F"
  • Are you rooting for Sessions as the underdog
  • Nibiru is Sumerian for 12th Planet From ancient Sumerian texts, there was a description that our creators came from a yet discovered planet that enters our Solar System ever 3,600 years.
  • What Archaeologists Really Think About Ancient Aliens, Lost Colonies, And Fingerprints Of The Gods
  • BEST SPEACH EVER 13 y/o Girl brings Down The House And Destroys Hillary Clinton At Trump Rally In Phoenix Arizona
  • Who is the best U.S. President over the last 100 years?
  • Is Sitchin correct – Is Nibiru a 12th planet that passes through our solar system every 3600 years? Did the Sumerians know this? Unfortunately for Sitchin and his followers, the answer to each of these questions is no.
  • Niger Fears an Influx of Gaddafi Loyalists.
  • Fusion GPS created Russian dossier to take out a sitting president
  • Lemuria, ancient lost civilization prior to Atlantis

Week in Review

  • View: Timeline
  • View: Sidebar
  • View: ClipCard
  • View: Mosaic
Powered by Blogger.